• Contact
21 / 03 / 2023
International Coalition for Papua
  • News
  • About Papua
  • Human Rights Report
    • Quarterly Reports
    • 2021
    • 2019
    • 2017
    • 2015
    • 2013
    • 2011
    • 2009
    • Genocide Report
  • Resources
    • International Law
      & Norms
    • National Laws
    • Political History
No Result
View All Result
International Coalition for Papua
  • News
  • About Papua
  • Human Rights Report
    • Quarterly Reports
    • 2021
    • 2019
    • 2017
    • 2015
    • 2013
    • 2011
    • 2009
    • Genocide Report
  • Resources
    • International Law
      & Norms
    • National Laws
    • Political History
International Coalition for Papua

New IPAC Report on West Papua – Diminished Autonomy and the Risk of New Flashpoints in Papua

28.12.2021
in 2021
Reading Time: 6 mins read
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

In 2014, President Joko Widodo promised a fresh approach to addressing the conflict in Papua. He acknowledged that Papuans need more than schools and roads: they need to be heard. But instead of listening to critics’ calls for a review of past mistakes, his administration continues to respond to rapidly escalating violence and deepening political grievances in Papua with a musty repertoire of top-down development initiatives. So far, none of it has worked. The Free Papua Movement (Organisasi Papua Merdeka, OPM) has grown stronger, racial tensions are flaring, street protests against the central government are mounting and Papua and Papua Barat remain the poorest of Indonesia’s provinces.

download-button

The long-planned revision of the Special Autonomy (Otsus) Law offered a chance to reset the deteriorating relationship between Jakarta and Papua. Both sides have long acknowledged that in its current form, special autonomy has delivered large amounts of poorly managed cash but failed to improve the lives of ordinary Papuans. However, the diagnosis of the problem and the solution sought by each side has been completely different.

The Jokowi government, like all governments before it, insisted that higher income and better infrastructure would make the demands for independence go away. Blaming corruption and mismanagement by Papuan elites for slow economic progress, the government sought to recentralize power by supervising spending and diffusing opposition to its own priorities in Papua.

Papuan activists have long contended that development alone cannot address what are fundamentally political grievances. This time around, there were two distinct views on the future of Otsus in Papua. One camp, led by the Papuan Peoples Council (Majelis Rakyat Papua, MRP) called for an exhaustive evaluation of the Otsus law through public consultations. A rejectionist camp, represented by the West Papua National Committee (Komite Nasional Papua Barat, KNPB), organized a mass petition to discard the special autonomy law in its entirety and demanded a referendum on independence.

The new Otsus Law, passed in July 2021, adopts the government’s proposal for recentralization and curtails Papua’s autonomy in three ways. First, it undermines the authority of provincial governors by recognizing local governments ( kabupaten/kota) as direct recipients of Otsus funds and empowers the central government to carve out new provinces and districts in Papua without the approval of the MRP or the provincial governments. Second, it allows the central government to supervise and control the allocation and disbursement of Otsus funds, a power previously reserved for the provincial government. Third, it removes the provision for institutional representation of indigenous Papuans through local political parties and replaces it with a quota for them in local legislatures along with preferential access to government-funded programmes.

The unilateral process through which the new law was drafted triggered widespread protests across Papua. The MRP, which by the terms of the 2001 law must be consulted on any revisions, was largely shut out of deliberations. Provincial officials were also sidelined. But instead of presenting the government with concrete alternatives, most Papuan leaders focused on demanding a seat at the table in Jakarta and lamenting their exclusion from the process.

Tensions were still running high in December 2021. The MRP has challenged both the process and the law’s substance in the Constitutional Court, where the case is still pending. The governor of Papua, who has had a tempestuous relationship with Jakarta, condemned provisions of the law and sparred with Jokowi’s ministers over the use of unused Otsus funds.

The Jokowi government is pushing ahead with the implementation of the new law, including its most contentious provision regarding the further carving up of Papua into new administrative units. The creation of Papua Selatan as a third province has long been on the government’s agenda. Officials insist that this is necessary for improving governance. Governor Enembe has persistently blocked the move, as it would significantly diminish his power. But now that the governors’ consent is no longer required, an expedited process will likely complete the split in 2022.

Whether or not the new law achieves the government’s stated objective of increasing economic growth in Papua remains to be seen. It is also unclear whether development, if it happens, benefits Papuans or non-Papuans. But steamrolling major cuts to Papua’s autonomy risks creating new flashpoints for violent mobilization. Unless Jokowi initiates a policy reset to bring Papuans on board with the government’s priorities, instead of accelerating development, the new law may end up accelerating conflict.

download-button

Previous Post

Update on situation of IDPs from Suru-Suru, Yahukimo Regency – Human rights defenders say 4,695 indigenous Papuans displaced, seven dead

Next Post

TAPOL releases video on torture and prosecution of displaced minor from Maybrat

Related Post

Constitutional Court rejects request to review law on formation of Irian Barat Province

Constitutional Court rejects request to review law on formation of Irian Barat Province

18.11.2021
IDPs situation in Maybrat Regency – Observers estimate number of IDPs rises to 3,000

IDPs situation in Maybrat Regency – Observers estimate number of IDPs rises to 3,000

17.11.2021

Security force operation in Puncak Regency – about 800 indigenous IDPs flee their homes

01.09.2019

Category

  • 2013
  • 2014
  • 2015
  • 2016
  • 2017
  • 2018
  • 2019
  • 2020
  • 2021
  • About Us
  • Biennial Report
  • CCPR Review 2013
  • CESCR Review 2014
  • Human Rights Report
  • International Law & Norms
  • National Laws
  • News
  • Political History
  • Quarterly Reports
  • Resources
  • Special Reports
  • Uncategorized

Tags

new (17)

ABOUT PAPUA

West Papua is the western half of the New Guinea island and comprises the two eastern-most Indonesian Provinces (Province Papua & Province Papua Barat). After decades of transmigration from other parts of Indonesia, the indigenous Melanesian population makes up less than 40% of the population.

Links

  • News
  • About Papua
  • Human Rights Report
  • Resources

Instagram Feed

    Go to the Customizer > JNews : Social, Like & View > Instagram Feed Setting, to connect your Instagram account.

Recent Post

Update on legal processes in relation to attack on military post in Maybrat – Lawyers call upon judges to acquit juvenile defendant

Update on law enforcement process in relation to attack on military post in Maybrat – six defendants transferred to Makassar for trial

31.12.2021
18 September 2021 marks end of palm oil moratorium in Indonesia – NGOs demand extension

Palm oil company PT Subur Karunia Raya alleged of breaching multiple laws in Teluk Bintuni

31.12.2021

© 2021 ICP - Webdesign by ➤ digitaleformate

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Human Rights Report
    • Quarterly Reports
    • 2019
    • 2017
    • 2015
    • 2013
    • 2011
    • 2009
    • Genocide Report
  • Resources
    • International Law & Norms
    • National Laws
    • Political History
  • About Us

© 2021 ICP - Webdesign by ➤ digitaleformate

Skip to content
Open toolbar

Accessibility Tools

  • Increase Text
  • Decrease Text
  • Grayscale
  • Links Underline
  • Readable Font
  • Reset